Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> There is only one "minor" issue: all major ISPs in my country ( Brazil ) only provide a single /64. You can't get another /64 unless you upgrade to a very expensive business plan.

I'm curious why you need multiple subnets at home; I at one point had separate subnets because I was using a wifi client as a ip level router, but was wondering what your use-case is.

> Although IPV4 + NAT had some issues, it ( accidentally? ) created a safe/sane default config for non-technical users. In order to open a port and expose a device, you have to explicitly add a rule on the firewall.

> IPv6 is the other way around. In practice, all devices and ports are exposed unless you explicitly block it.

I would like to humbly suggest that you don't remember what the internet was around the turn of the century with devices configuring IGD via UPnP so every device you hooked up to your home router automatically setup a port-mapping to put itself on the open internet.

Eventually everyone realized this sucked and UPnP NAT traversal was disabled everywhere. The same will happen (and actually more-or-less has already happened) with default-allow home routers switching to default-block.



>I'm curious why you need multiple subnets at home; I at one point had separate subnets because I was using a wifi client as a ip level router, but was wondering what your use-case is.

Not OP, but there are many use cases. First is device isolation so untrusted devices can be put in their own network while you can selectively add ressources from your main network via VLANs and add simple firewall rules because the untrusted network is a different interface on your VM than the others.

Second, you might want to put any managment interfaces (and ssh-enabled IPs) on a seperate network both for ease of organization and security.

Third, if you want to have your network services configured differently for different clients (think VPN vs local clients, adblocking DNS for mobile only) it's a lot easier to do that for whole subnets.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: